Carduus benedictus

Carduus benedictus

Cnicus benedictus · Plant · Asteraceae

Clarke

Carduus Benedictus has a strong action on the eyes (twitchings, visual disturbances, feeling of enlarged eyeballs), the respiratory tract (contracted trachea, hoarseness, cold inspired air), and the digestive system (bitter burning in stomach, dysphagia). The running thread through the proving is a sensation of contraction in many parts. Burning and varicosis of veins are also notable features.

Key symptoms

  • Twitchings and disturbance of vision; flickering fiery stars before eyes
  • Eyeballs feel larger; blackness before eyes transiently
  • Sensation of contraction in many parts, especially trachea and buccal cavity
  • Bitter burning in the stomach as if greatly deranged
  • Pain in the trachea as if inflamed; inspired air feels cold
  • Cracking and aching in joints with difficult motion
  • Aching and slight swelling of veins

Worse (aggravation)

  • Motion and walking
  • Touch and pressure
  • Stretching the limbs
  • Stooping (vertigo and head pressure worse)

Better (amelioration)

  • After eating (buccal contraction sensation improves)
John Henry Clarke
A Dictionary of Practical Materia Medica · 1900

Cnicus benedictus. Centaurea benedicta. N. O. Compositæ. Tincture of whole plant when in flower.

Clinical

Amaurosis. Diarrhœa. Eyes, affections of. Fever. Headache. Joints, cracking of. Œsophagus, stricture of. Varicosis. Vision, affections of.

Characteristics

The proving of Card. ben. shows a strong action on the eyes: twitchings, and disturbance of vision; flickerings; muscæ volitantes. The prover had "blackness before eyes for a short time." Eyeballs feel larger. "Burning" is a symptom which runs through the proving. There is a "bitter burning" in the stomach, as if it were much deranged; burning in hands after sweat; burning in the arms on exerting them. The gastro-abdominal disturbances of Card. mar. are observed, in less degree, in Card. ben. There is disordered taste, dysphagia; yawning and hiccough; cutting pains in abdomen, vomiting and diarrhœa. The respiratory sphere is strongly affected and there is pain and contractive sensation in the trachea with hoarseness. Inspired air feels cold. Other …

Continue Clarke in the app

Classical texts are in the public domain. Educational reference only — not medical advice.

Read every author on Carduus benedictus
Open app